Hi, I have checked your old website and I will redesign the website into WordPress now so that you can easily manage the website in the near future. The feel and the colors, I will keep them the same but will give the site a more good and professional look. You want to integrate the Paypal, do you need a product page too where you can add the products and people can from there?
Let me know about this and I am here to help you.
We have a small team of talented and dedicated developers experienced in responsive web development - Wordpress/PHP(Core, Codeignitor, Laravel) /HTML/CSS/Bootstrap